The Turntable System
Introduction: The Turntable as a System
The Turntable System
In the realm of high-fidelity audio, the turntable stands out as a unique and intricate system, distinct from more straightforward "enclosed" components, like the cassette deck or open reel tape machines, CD players, AM/FM Tuners, or digital music streamers. While all these devices serve the fundamental purpose of playing music, the turntable’s design and operation embody a more complex and interactive approach to sound reproduction.
This complexity is not merely a matter of nostalgia or aesthetic preference; it reflects a deeper engagement with the physical and mechanical aspects of audio playback.
A turntable is not just a single piece of equipment but a system composed of several interdependent components: the plinth, the bearing, the platter, the tonearm, the cartridge, and the need for specialised circuitry of a phono pre-amp. Each element plays a critical role in the overall performance, and their interactions can significantly influence the sound quality.
This contrasts sharply with a "closed component" like a CD player, which operates as a more integrated and automated device, where the digital-to-analog conversion and playback mechanisms are largely self-contained and less susceptible to user intervention.
​
The rationale behind the turntable as a system lies in its ability to offer a highly customisable and tactile listening experience. Audiophiles appreciate the opportunity to fine-tune each component to achieve the desired sound signature, from selecting the platter mat properties to the selection of the perfect cartridge to adjusting the tracking force and anti-skate settings.
This level of customisation allows for a more personalised and immersive engagement with music, where the listener can directly influence the playback characteristics.
​​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​​
​Moreover, the analogue nature of vinyl records and turntables introduces a distinct sonic signature of the materials used in the construction of the turntable, the resonance qualities of the materials of the turntable ad to the warmth and richness to the sound, often described as more natural and engaging compared to the clinical precision of digital formats.
​
The physical interaction with the record, from carefully placing the stylus to manually flipping the vinyl, adds a ritualistic element to the listening experience, enhancing the emotional connection to the music.
​
In summary, the turntable as a system represents a holistic approach to audio playback, where each component’s contribution is meticulously considered and optimised.
This contrasts with the more uniform and automated operation of CD and digital music players, highlighting the turntable’s unique appeal to those who value both the technical and experiential aspects of high-fidelity sound reproduction.
​
Vibration Control of Unwanted Plinth Vibrations
Vibration Propagation and Turntable Performance:
When the stylus is tracking the record groove it is an intricate process, one that is deeply sensitive to vibrations. The stylus reads the microscopic contours of the groove, converting these physical undulations into electrical signals.
These signals are then amplified to produce sound, capturing the nuances and subtleties of the original recording. This ability to extract fine details makes vinyl playback cherished among audiophiles. However, this sensitivity also means that the stylus is highly susceptible to unwanted vibrations, which can significantly affect sound quality.
The vibrations created by the stylus when tracking the record create vibrations within the turntable these vibrations are easily heard without amplifier or speakers turned on, and those very same vibrations adversely impact the vibrations of the stylus while tracking the groove.
​
As the stylus moves through the groove, it inevitably generates its own vibrations. These vibrations travel through the vinyl record causing the record itself to resonate. The platter, which supports the vinyl, then picks up these vibrations, and if not properly damped, transmits them throughout the rest of the turntable structure. This creates a feedback loop where vibrations generated by the stylus are reflected back, affecting its performance and introducing distortions.
​
Ironically, the very vibrations that allow the stylus to produce such detailed sound also make it vulnerable to these adverse effects. The vibrations can travel from the stylus to the tonearm, arm-board, and plinth (the base of the turntable), each potentially adding its own resonance and further complicating the playback. These reflections and resonances create a delayed reflection, causing the stylus to pick up extraneous noise that interferes with the original signal, creating a smearing of sorts to the sound, an ever so slightly out of focus leading edge to the sound.
​
Therefore, controlling these vibrations through effective damping and isolation techniques is crucial. The choice of materials used in the construction of the platter, plinth, and the arm-board, as well as additional vibration isolation accessories, all play significant roles in minimising these unwanted resonances. By carefully managing these vibrations, the integrity of the audio signal can be preserved, ensuring that the playback remains true to the original recording and free from distortion.
​
Additionally the external vibrations both airborne and mechanical from the speakers, creating vibrations of the floor and equipment rack, even you walking across the room, each step you take is picked up by the stylus. ​The stylus is very sensitive to vibration, and it's that sensitivity that makes it so good at bringing out nuances from a record groove.
​
Turntable design has evolved significantly over the years, incorporating cutting-edge technologies and engineering principles from various advanced fields. Extraordinary design and engineering concepts traditionally used in aeronautical, medical, and scientific disciplines have been adapted to create some of the world's best turntables, pushing the boundaries of vinyl playback performance.
​
In the aeronautical industry, the emphasis on precision engineering and material science has inspired turntable manufacturers to utilise high-performance materials like carbon fiber and aerospace-grade aluminum. These materials offer exceptional strength-to-weight ratios, minimising resonance and ensuring accurate sound reproduction. The precision machining techniques used in aeronautics have also been applied to turntable components, enhancing the overall build quality and reliability of the systems.
​
Medical engineering, known for its focus on reducing vibrations and ensuring stability, has contributed techniques such as constrained-layer damping and vibration isolation. These methods are crucial in medical devices to maintain accuracy and functionality, and when applied to turntables, they effectively minimise unwanted vibrations that can distort audio signals. This results in a clearer and more faithful reproduction of the original recording.
​
Scientific fields, particularly those involved in instrumentation and measurement, have influenced the development of advanced tonearm designs and bearing mechanisms. For example, the use of magnetic bearings, which provide frictionless movement, and negative stiffness suspension systems, which isolate the platter from external vibrations, are concepts borrowed from scientific instrumentation. These innovations ensure that the stylus tracks the record groove with unparalleled precision, reducing tracking errors and enhancing sound quality.
​
Overall, the integration of these advanced technologies and engineering practices from aeronautical, medical, and scientific fields has propelled turntable design to new heights. By leveraging these sophisticated techniques, modern turntables are capable of delivering exceptional audio fidelity, allowing audiophiles to experience vinyl playback with unprecedented clarity and detail. This cross-disciplinary approach not only showcases the versatility of engineering solutions but also highlights the continuous pursuit of perfection in the world of high-fidelity audio.
​​
Construction Materials & Resonance
The Influence of Construction Materials on Turntable Performance:
​
The choice of materials used in the construction of turntables plays a pivotal role in the playback performance of vinyl records. This influence stems primarily from the materials’ resonance qualities and their ability to either dampen or exacerbate vibrations. Each aspect of a turntable, from the plinth to platter, tonearm to the chassis and feet, relies on the control these material properties to maintain the integrity of the audio signal and ensure high-fidelity sound reproduction, control of the Vibrations of the materials controlling resonances of turntables individual components brings record playback into focus.
​​
​
​
​
​
​
​
Platter and Mat:
The turntable platter plays a crucial role in the performance of vinyl playback, acting as the platform upon which the record sits and spins. It is connected to the turntable's bearing and motor drive system.
The connection between the platter, bearing, and motor is also a pathway for noise transmission. Mechanical vibrations and noise generated by the tracking stylus can travel through the platter, to bearing and and manifest as acoustic reflections. These unwanted vibrations are transferred to the cartridge, creating a feedback loop where noise travels from the cartridge to the plinth via the platter and bearing, and is then reflected back, distorting the audio signal. Additionally, acoustic reflections can occur from the cartridge to the arm-board and plinth through the tonearm, further complicating the noise issue. These "feedback" loops of delayed acoustic reflections can mask or interfere with the original sound, reducing clarity and detail. Thus, effective isolation and damping techniques are crucial in turntable design to minimize these disturbances and maintain high-fidelity playback.
​
The selection of platter materials impact many facets of the turntable system, as a key central component to the the vinyl record during playback. The platter has the ability to significantly influence the resonate behavior and reflection of the cartridge stylus. Common materials for platters include metals like aluminum and steel, as well as acrylic and glass. Metals, while durable, can introduce unwanted resonances and "grain" to the sound, as well as electrical interference to the cartridge.
Metal platters can introduce electrical noise and vibrations due to their conductive properties. When the stylus of the cartridge tracks the record, any electrical potential difference between the metal platter and the cartridge can create a small current, potentially leading to hum or buzz in the audio signal. Additionally, metal platters can act as a ground loop, where electrical currents circulate through the turntable's components, causing unwanted noise.
Platter vibrations if not properly damped, are only the beginning of the challenges the platter must address.
Acrylic and glass, on the other hand, offer better intrinsic damping properties, leading to more stable and accurate playback. The choice of mat, which sits between the record and the platter, further affects sound quality. Rubber and cork mats are popular for their vibration absorption capabilities, while felt mats offer minimal damping but are favored for their neutrality.
​​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
Tonearm:
The tonearm must be both lightweight and rigid to accurately track the grooves of a vinyl record without introducing resonance. Materials like carbon fiber and aluminum are commonly used due to their high strength-to-weight ratios. Carbon fiber, in particular, excels at minimizing resonance, providing a cleaner and more detailed sound. The design and material of the tonearm contribute significantly to the overall tonal balance and resolution of the playback.
​
Chassis and Plinth:
The chassis or plinth of a turntable houses all the components and provides the foundation for the entire system. It must be robust and well-damped to isolate the turntable from external vibrations. Materials like MDF (Medium Density Fiberboard), solid wood, and various composites are frequently used. MDF and composites are preferred for their excellent damping properties, which reduce the transfer of vibrations from the environment to the turntable. Solid wood, while aesthetically pleasing, can introduce resonances if not properly engineered.
​
Feet and Isolation:
The feet of a turntable are crucial for isolating the unit from vibrations transmitted through the surface on which it sits. High-quality turntables often feature adjustable feet made from materials like rubber, silicone, or specialized damping compounds. These materials help decouple the turntable from its resting surface, minimizing the impact of external vibrations and improving overall sound quality.
​​​
Resonance and Damping:
Resonance is the tendency of a material to vibrate at specific frequencies, and managing these vibrations is essential for high-fidelity playback. Effective damping materials and techniques are employed to mitigate resonances. Constrained layer damping, where layers of different materials are bonded together to dissipate vibrations, is one method used in turntable design. This approach helps ensure that resonances do not interfere with the audio signal, preserving the purity of the sound.
​
Conclusion:
The materials used in turntable construction have a profound impact on playback performance. From the platter and tonearm to the chassis and feet, each component's material properties influence how vibrations and resonances are managed. By carefully selecting and engineering these materials, manufacturers can create turntables that offer superior sound quality, faithfully reproducing the nuances of vinyl records. The interplay of material choice and design is fundamental to achieving the ultimate vinyl listening experience, where every detail of the music is captured with clarity and precision.
​
